Version: Loading...
The 1987 case BP Properties Ltd v Buckler concerned Great House Farm, Llandough — property long occupied by the Williams/Buckler family. The court ruled against the family based on the argument that Mrs Mary Williams (referred to as "Mrs Buckler" in court documents) did not formally reject an offer made by BP Properties Ltd, treating that as tacit acceptance.
However, she had already explicitly rejected prior licence attempts by BP Pension Trust Ltd, a related BP entity. The judge ruled that BP Properties Ltd was a distinct legal entity, making her prior rejection legally irrelevant. Later, in her son's appeal, the court dismissed the appeal, ruling that "BP companies are all effectively one and the same."
This contradictory reasoning — treating the companies as separate when it benefited BP, but as the same when it benefited the Bucklers — represents a procedural inconsistency amounting to bias, which may justify reopening under CPR 52.30 and Limitations Act Section 32.
Great House Farm (Ty Mawr) dates to the early 16th century. The Williams family claim occupation from 1667. In 1870, a Roman soldier in full armor was discovered under the living room floor during renovations. Guglielmo Marconi stayed with the family while conducting wireless telegraphy experiments at Lavernock Point in 1897.
Key dates: 1667 (Williams family acquisition), 1876 (quarry agreement with Daniel Thomas), 1916 (agricultural tenancy to John Williams), 1955 (tenancy terminated), 1974 (unilateral license letters), 1982 (land registration), 1987 (court case), 1988 (demolition).
The Bute Estate Records (Series D 219, NLW) show manorial leases from 1552-1829 treating the Bute/Pembroke estate as superior landholder. The "Llandough manorial leases and agreements" explicitly covers Great House Farm (c. 166 acres). An 1820 memorandum shows Bute taking control of farms including "Great House Farm alias Cedfin".
Family testimony states a 1667 acquisition and a later Daniel Thomas/Bute deal in the early 1900s allowing quarrying in exchange for title. The missing deeds referred to in court records — allegedly stolen from Cardiff Library in 1984 — would prove this chain. The 1900s conveyance would shift legal framing from occupation to ownership.